Toasted Orlando

4 out of 5 sprouts

4 out of 5 sprouts

Toasted Orlando recently opened in Winter Park offering the ultimate comfort food- the grilled cheese sandwich.  Toasted steps it up a notch or two- offering many gourmet variations of the classic cheese icon.

Periodic Table of Cheese- Toasted Orlando

Even better, Toasted offers vegan versions of most of their sandwiches.  The vegan cheese is made in house with coconut milk and they also make their own veggie burgers.

Viva La Vegan Toasted Orlando

Chad ordered the Viva La Vegan– the homemade veggie burger topped with a secret Toasted sauce, spicy tomato chutney and arugula.  I had to grab a bite of this and it was delicious- we are always on the lookout for a great veggie burger and there is nothing ordinary about this one.  No cardboard taste here like some places.  It was hearty and filling.

Blackberry Melt Toasted Orlando

I went for the Blackberry Melt.  The version on the regular menu is made with a blackberry mash, Fontina cheese, bacon and arugula.  However, I opted for the Vegan version- Vegan cheese, the blackberry mash, arugula and portabella mushrooms.  An “A” for effort but the Vegan thing doesn’t work here.  It was essentially a jelly and cheese sandwich.  The blackberry mash was very good but very sweet- too sweet.  The sandwich really needs the bacon to add the saltiness the Vegan version is needing.

The Big Cheese Toasted Orlando

I ended up ordering another sandwich- I went for the Big Cheese (the non-Vegan version)- this was more of a traditional grilled cheese- Jack cheese, Muenster, white cheddar and arugula on “locally sourced artisan bread.”  Really, the bread makes the sandwich.

Truffle and Rosemary Fries

We also ordered a side of fries (one order is big enough for two people to share) and these also had a great twist.  They were made with truffle oil and fresh rosemary and they were quite tasty.  Sometimes there is nothing better to pair with a good ol’ fashioned grilled cheese sammy like a tasty order of fresh hot fries.  Yum.

The manager (or the owner?) had heard that I was not pleased with the Vegan Blackberry Melt and actually made it a point to step over to our table and gave me a card for a free meal next visit.  Honestly, I didn’t go out of my way to complain- it was the attentive girl behind the counter who noticed I had ordered another sandwich and she took it upon herself to let the manager know I had ordered another sandwich.  That was a really nice personal touch.  I was very impressed.

Vegan Menu- Toasted OrlandoThe Vegan menu offers five grilled cheese varieties and three veggie burger options.  There are also a few salads on the menu.  Next time I am going with the recommendation of the nice girl behind the counter who said that the Forever Fall is her personal favorite sandwich- roasted sweet potatoes, apple chutney and cheese on that great artisan bread.

Also interesting to note, make sure you take the time to read the Periodic Table of Cheese on the wall.  Hilarious.

The Periodic Table of Cheese- Toasted Orlando

Periodic Table of Cheese wall

Ricotta- Toasted Orlando


Toasted Orlando

We really enjoyed this place and will be excited to visit again and try some more of the Vegan Grilled Cheese versions. 

Toasted website.

Toasted on Urbanspoon Toasted on Foodio54

NOTE: We visited again in April 2014- here are the pictures from that visit. We had the Viva La Vegan burger again as well as the Fig and Honey Grilled Cheese. The Fig and Honey had fig jam, honey and basil.

Viva La Vegan

Truffle Fries

Fig and Honey

2 comments for “Toasted Orlando

  1. Helen Corbin
    June 18, 2013 at 11:29 am

    I have GOT TO STOP reading this blog until AFTER I have eaten :-( I always want what you are having (in this case what Chad had.

    • Chad
      July 16, 2013 at 11:31 am

      Yeah my burger was good. And the fries were good too.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge